ID: 481

I have 350 examples that were annotated with binary labels by two different annotators. How do I compute inter-annotator agreement, including confidence interval?

Aligned LLM's Response:

Great , I ' m here to help ! Comput ing inter - annot ator agreement is an important task in machine learning , especially when working with annot ated data . Here ' s a step - by - step guide on how to compute inter - annot ator agreement , including confidence intervals , using your 3 5 0 annot ated examples : \n 1 . Calcul ate the An notation Ag re ement : \n First , calculate the annotation agreement between the two annot ators using the following formula : \n Annotation Ag re ement = ( Number of Ag re ed Ex amples ) / ( Total Number of Ex amples ) \n Where " Number of Ag re ed Ex amples " is the number of examples that both annot ators l abeled in the same way , and " Total Number of Ex amples " is the total number of examples in the dataset . \n For example , if the two annot ators agreed on 1 0 0 out of 3 5 0 examples , the annotation agreement would be 0 . 2 9 ( 1 0 0 / 3 5 0 ). \n 2 . Calcul ate the Inter - An not ator Dist ance : \n Next , calculate the inter - annot ator distance using the following formula : \n Inter - An not ator Dist ance = ( Max imum An notation D ifference ) / ( Min imum An notation Ag re ement ) \n Where " Max imum An notation D ifference " is the maximum difference between the two annot ators ' labels for any example , and " Min imum An notation Ag re ement " is the minimum agreement between the two annot ators ' labels for any example . \n For example , if the maximum annotation difference between the two annot ators was 5 and the minimum annotation agreement was 0 . 2 , the inter - annot ator distance would be 5 / 0 . 2 = 2 5 . \n 3 . Calcul ate the Conf idence Inter val : \n To calculate the confidence interval , you can use a statistical method called the B eta Distribution . The B eta Distribution is a continuous probability distribution that models the probability of a binary outcome ( e . g ., agreement or disag re ement ) based on two underlying probability values ( e . g ., the proportion of agreement and the proportion of disag re ement ). \n Here ' s how to calculate the confidence interval using the B eta Distribution : \n a . Calcul ate the proportion of agreement ( p ) and the proportion of disag re ement ( q ) between the two annot ators using the annotation agreement value . \n p = An notation Ag re ement \n q = 1 - p \n b . Calcul ate the beta values ( β 1 and β 2 ) using the following formulas : \n β 1 = ( p \ * ( 1 - p )) / ( q \ * ( 1 - q )) \n β 2 = ( q \ * ( 1 - q )) / ( p \ * ( 1 - p )) \n c . Calcul ate the confidence interval using the B eta Distribution function : \n Conf idence Inter val = B ( β 1 , β 2 ) \n Where B ( β 1 , β 2 ) is the B eta Distribution function with parameters β 1 and β 2 . \n For example , if the annotation agreement was 0 . 3 , the proportion of agreement was 0 . 3 , and the proportion of disag re ement was 0 . 7 , the beta values would be β 1 = 0 . 4 3 and β 2 = 0 . 5 7 . Using these values , you could calculate the confidence interval as follows : \n Conf idence Inter val = B ( 0 . 4 3 , 0 . 5 7 ) \n This confidence interval represents the range of values within which the true inter - annot ator agreement is likely to fall . \n 4 . Inter pret the Results : \n Fin ally , interpret the results of your inter - annot ator agreement analysis . The confidence interval provides a range of values within which the true inter - annot ator agreement is likely to fall . You can use this information to assess the reli ability of your annot ators and to make dec isions about how to proceed with your machine learning model . \n For example , if the confidence interval is wide ( e . g ., 9 5 % confidence interval ), it may indicate that the annot ators have different interpret ations of the data , and you may need to re - annot ate the examples or use multiple annot ators to improve the agreement . On the other hand , if the confidence interval is narrow ( e . g ., 9 9 % confidence interval ), it may indicate that the annot ators have a high level of agreement , and you can use their labels to train your machine learning model . \n That ' s it ! By following these steps , you can compute inter - annot ator agreement , including confidence intervals , for your 3 5 0 annot ated examples . </s>

Legend: Shifted positions  |  Marginal positions  |  Unshifted positions

Token Distributions

Previous
Home
Next